skip to main content

A Better 3D Conformal Approach in Glioblastoma Proximates Intensity Modulated One: A Dosimetric Study

Sadiq Ullah  -  Department of Medical Physics, CENAR Hospital Quetta Pakistan, Pakistan
Hashir Saeed  -  Department of Medical Physics, CENAR Hospital Quetta Pakistan, Pakistan
*Sunnia Shafiq  -  Department of Medical Physics, CENAR Hospital Quetta Pakistan, Pakistan
Hafiz Khush Naseeb Ahmad  -  Department of Nuclear Medicine, CENAR Hospital Quetta Pakistan, Pakistan
Hina Manzoor  -  Department of Medical Physics, CENAR Hospital Quetta Pakistan, Pakistan
Received: 9 Sep 2024; Revised: 5 Feb 2025; Accepted: 21 Feb 2025; Available online: 31 May 2025; Published: 31 May 2025.

Citation Format:
Abstract

This study aimed to evaluate whether Three-Dimensional Conformal Radiation Therapy (3D-CRT) could achieve results comparable to Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy (IMRT) in treating grade 4 glioblastoma. Treatment plans for 80 consecutive patients with grade 4 glioblastoma, treated between January 1, 2020, and July 31, 2024, were developed using 3D-CRT and IMRT. 3D-CRT utilized three to five fields with dynamic wedges and the field-in-field technique, while IMRT employed seven fields with homogeneous angles. Target coverage was set to ensure that 97% of the isodose covered 98% of the Planning Target Volume (PTV). Both 3D-CRT and IMRT achieved similar target coverage. However, IMRT showed superior homogeneity (0.053 vs. 0.097) and conformity (1.187 vs. 1.663) compared to 3D-CRT. IMRT also provided better sparing of normal brain tissue and surrounding organs, except for the contralateral eye, though it required longer treatment delivery time due to higher Monitor Units (MUs). IMRT additionally limited low-dose escalation. IMRT outperforms 3D-CRT in homogeneity, conformity, and sparing organs at risk, despite the longer treatment time. 3D-CRT may approximate IMRT when the target volume is not near critical structures but still results in greater low-dose exposure to normal brain tissue for the same target coverage.

Fulltext View|Download
Keywords: Three-Dimensional Conformal Radiation Therapy; Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy;Glioblastoma,;Monitor Units,;Brain tissue
Funding: Nil

Article Metrics:

  1. ‎E. Bakiu, E. Telhaj, E. Kozma, and F. Ruci, "Comparison of 3D CRT and IMRT Treatment Plans" ACTA INFORM MED, 21, 211-212, (2013)
  2. A. Narayana, J. Yamada, S. Berry, P. Shah, and M. Hunt, "Intensity-modulated radiotherapy in high grade gliomas: clinical and dosimetric results" Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 64, 892-897, (2006)
  3. D. Petrova, S. Smickovska, and E. Lazarevska, "Conformity Index and Homogeneity Index of the Postoperative Whole Breast Radiotherapy" Journal of Medical Sciences, 5, 736-739, (2017)
  4. D. Wagner, H. Christiansen, H. Wolff, and H. Vorwerk, "Radiotherapy of malignant gliomas: comparison of volumetric single arc technique (RapidArc), dynamic intensity-modulated technique and 3D conformal technique" Radiother Oncol, 93, 593-596, (2009)
  5. L. Zach, B. Stall, H. Ning, J. Ondos, B. Arora, and S. Uma, "A dosimetric comparison of four treatment planning methods for high grade glioma" Radiat Oncol, 4, 45, (2009)
  6. I. K. M. Lauren R. Schaff, "Glioblastoma and Other Primary Brain Malignancies in Adults" Jama, 329, 574-587, (2023)
  7. Vilashini Rajaratnam, M. M. I. M. Y. R. S. M. R., and S. P. M., "Glioblastoma: Pathogenesis and Current Status of Chemotherapy and Other Novel Treatments" Cancers, 12, 937, (2020)
  8. S. M. MacDonald, S. Ahmad, S. Kachris, B. J. Vogds, M. DeRouen, A. E. Gittelman, K. DeWyngaert, and M. T. Vlachaki, "Intensity modulated radiation therapy versus three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy for the treatment of high-grade glioma: a dosimetric comparison" Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, 8, 47-60, (2007)
  9. S. Lorentini, D. Amelio, M. G. Giri, F. Fellin, G. Meliado, A. Rizzotti, M. Amichetti, and M. Schwarz, "IMRT or 3DCRT in Glioblastoma? A Dosimetric Criterion for Patient Selection" Technology in Cancer Research and Treatment, 12, 411-420, (2013)
  10. Stephen Morris, T. R. S. A. S. L., Practical Radiotherapy Planning Boca Raton: CRC Press, (2023)
  11. D. Thibouw, G. Truc, A. Bertaut, C. Chevalier, L. Aubignac, and C. Mirjolet, "Clinical and dosimetric study of radiotherapy for glioblastoma: three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy versus intensity-modulated radiotherapy" Journal of Neuro-Oncology, (2018)
  12. Aveline Marie D. Ylanan, J. S. G. P., E. M. D. C.-L. K. H. D. I. J. P. A. K. J. O. K., "Intraoperative radiotherapy for glioblastoma: A systematic review of techniques and outcomes" Journal of Clinical Neuroscience, 93, 36-41, (2021)
  13. D. Amelio, S. Lorentini, M. Schwarz, and M. Amichetti, "Intensity-modulated radiation therapy in newly diagnosed glioblastoma: A systematic review on clinical and technical issues" Radiotherapy and Oncology, 97, 361-369, (2010)
  14. M. F. Chan, K. Schupak, C. Burman, C.-S. Chui, and C. C. Ling, "Comparison of intensity-modulated radiotherapy with three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy planning for glioblastoma multiforme" Medical Dosimetry, 28, 261-265, (2003)
  15. U. Hermanto, E. K. Frija, M. J. L., E. L. Chang, A. Mahajan, and S. Y. Woo, "Intensity-Modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) and Conventional three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy for high grade gliomas: Does IMRT increase integral dose to normal brain?" Radiation Oncology, 67, 1135-1144, (2007)
  16. Daniel M. Trifiletti, M. T. M., K. J. R. E. L. P. J. A. H. M. M. K., "Treatment Planning Expansions in Glioblastoma: How Less Can Be More" International Journal of Radiation Oncology Biology Physics, 117, 293-296, (2023)
  17. L. S. Huai, Cheng, J. C. Hsien, K. S. Hsin, and L. J. J. Shenn, "Volumetric modulated arc therapy for nasopharyngeal carcinoma: A dosimetric comparison with TomoTherapy and step-and-shoot IMRT" Radiotherapy and Oncology, 104, 324-330, (2012)
  18. N. P. Brodin and W. A. Tome, "Revisiting the dose constraints for head and neck OARs in the current era of IMRT" Oral Oncology, 86, 8-18, (2018)
  19. M. Piroth, M. Pinkawa, R. Holy, G. Stoffels, C. Demirel, and C. Attieh, "Integrated-boost IMRT or 3-D-CRT using FET-PET based auto-contoured target volume delineation for glioblastoma multiforme-a dosimetric comparison" Radiation Oncology, 4, 57, (2009)

Last update:

No citation recorded.

Last update:

No citation recorded.